Skip to content
Ordinary Time

Reasoning & Fallacies

Appeal to Authority

noun

Treating a claim as proven just because an authority asserts it — fallacious when the authority is irrelevant, biased, or not actually expert.

Also called: argumentum ad verecundiam

Not To Be Confused With

Citing real experts is legitimate and often wise; it becomes a fallacy when the authority is outside their field, when experts disagree, or when “he said so” replaces evidence.

Authorities are valuable witnesses, not infallible proofs. A church father or scholar quoted on a point still has to be weighed; “a great name said it” is testimony to consider, not a conclusion to end the argument. In theology, even genuine authorities are read under Scripture and reason.

Related Terms

Seen In These Debates

Appeal to Authority — Definition | Theologos Media | Theologos Media